Back to Magazine
Strategies • 5 min read

Balance Transfer vs Personal Loan for Debt Payoff

Two popular options for consolidating debt—but which one will save you more money?

You've got credit card debt and you're ready to get serious about paying it off. Two options keep coming up: balance transfer cards and personal loans. Both can save you money on interest, but they work very differently.

Let's break down which one makes sense for your situation.

Balance Transfer Cards: The Basics

A balance transfer card lets you move existing credit card debt to a new card with a 0% introductory APR—typically for 12-21 months.

How it works:

  1. Apply for a balance transfer card
  2. Transfer balances from existing cards
  3. Pay 0% interest during the intro period
  4. Pay off the debt before the intro period ends

The costs:

  • Transfer fee: Usually 3-5% of the amount transferred
  • Regular APR after intro: Typically 18-26%

Example: $10,000 balance transfer

  • Transfer fee (3%): $300
  • Monthly payment to pay off in 18 months: $556
  • Total paid: $10,300
  • Interest saved vs. keeping it on a 24% card: ~$3,700

Try It Yourself

See your personalized numbers with our free calculator.

Open Balance Transfer Calculator

Personal Loans: The Basics

A personal loan gives you a lump sum at a fixed interest rate that you repay over a set term (usually 2-7 years).

How it works:

  1. Apply for a personal loan
  2. Receive funds and pay off credit cards
  3. Make fixed monthly payments until the loan is paid off

The costs:

  • Interest rate: Typically 8-20% depending on credit
  • Origination fee: 0-8% of loan amount
  • Fixed payment and payoff date

Example: $10,000 personal loan at 12% for 36 months

  • Monthly payment: $332
  • Total interest paid: ~$1,960
  • Interest saved vs. keeping it on a 24% card: ~$4,000

Head-to-Head Comparison

Factor Balance Transfer Personal Loan
Interest rate 0% (temporary) 8-20% (fixed)
Upfront cost 3-5% fee 0-8% origination
Time to pay off 12-21 months 24-84 months
Monthly payment Higher (shorter term) Lower (longer term)
Discipline required High Moderate
Credit score needed Good (680+) Fair to Good (640+)

When to Choose a Balance Transfer

A balance transfer card is your best bet if:

You Can Pay It Off in Time

This is the big one. If you can realistically pay off the balance during the 0% period, a balance transfer usually wins. No interest beats low interest.

Do the math: $10,000 ÷ 18 months = $556/month. Can you swing that?

You Have Good Credit

The best balance transfer offers require credit scores of 680+. Below that, you might not get approved or might get a shorter intro period.

You Trust Yourself Not to Add More Debt

Balance transfer cards are still credit cards. If you transfer $10,000 and then charge another $5,000, you've made your situation worse.

Your Debt Is Under $15-20K

Most balance transfer cards have limits. If you have $30,000 in debt, you might not be able to transfer it all.

When to Choose a Personal Loan

A personal loan makes more sense if:

You Need More Time to Pay Off

Personal loans offer longer terms (3-7 years), which means lower monthly payments. If $556/month isn't realistic but $332/month is, the loan might work better.

You Want a Guaranteed Payoff Date

With a personal loan, the math is simple: make your payments, and you're done on date X. No worrying about a promotional rate expiring.

You Need the Structure

Personal loans are installment loans, not revolving credit. You can't keep borrowing. For some people, this forced structure is exactly what they need.

Your Credit Isn't Great

Personal loans are available to borrowers with credit scores in the 640-680 range. The rate won't be amazing, but it'll likely beat credit card rates.

You Have a Lot of Debt

Personal loans can go up to $50,000 or more, making them suitable for larger debt consolidation projects.

The Hidden Risks

Balance Transfer Traps:

  1. Deferred interest: Some cards charge retroactive interest if you don't pay in full by the end of the promo period. Read the fine print!

  2. High post-promo rates: When 0% ends, rates can jump to 24%+. Any remaining balance gets expensive fast.

  3. New purchases: Many cards charge regular APR on new purchases while you're paying off the transfer. Don't use the card for anything new.

Personal Loan Traps:

  1. Origination fees: A 5% fee on a $10,000 loan means you're effectively borrowing $9,500 but owe $10,000.

  2. Prepayment penalties: Some loans charge fees for paying off early. Avoid these.

  3. Longer timelines: A lower payment over 7 years might cost more total interest than higher payments over 3 years.

A Hybrid Approach

Some people use both:

  1. Transfer what you can to a 0% card
  2. Take a personal loan for the rest
  3. Attack the balance transfer aggressively
  4. Pay off the personal loan over time

This captures the 0% savings while keeping the overflow at a reasonable rate.

The Deciding Questions

Ask yourself:

  1. What's my total debt? (Under $15K? Balance transfer might cover it)

  2. What monthly payment can I afford? (Divide debt by 18. Is that doable?)

  3. How's my credit? (680+? You have options. 640-680? Lean toward personal loan)

  4. Am I disciplined with credit cards? (Honestly? If no, personal loan)

  5. What rates can I actually get? (Check pre-qualification offers)

Try It Yourself

See your personalized numbers with our free calculator.

Open Debt Consolidation Calculator

The Bottom Line

  • Balance transfer = Best for disciplined payers who can clear debt in 12-21 months
  • Personal loan = Best for those who need structure and longer payoff timelines

Neither option works unless you stop adding new debt and commit to consistent payments. The tool matters less than the commitment.

Run the numbers for your specific situation and make the choice that fits your life.

Related Articles